Edu INDEX: EVERYTHING GOOD AND EVERYTHING BAD IS BORN IN THE SCHOOLS
We say that it comes from the history of our past, and from our upbringing through our parents and peers, but it is the schools that reinforce it all, and put their own indelible stamp on it.
[I’ll amend the title to acknowledge in antiquity there were no schools. There was religion and superstition, and of course beliefs were passed on by ruthless social pressure. what is the nature of these linguistic systems?]
I’ll use Berea College in Kentucky as the icon for the master INDEX.
I have collected a lot of reading on education in America, but I have never really immersed myself in it, always postponing. Of course it is the primary root interest about every other thing. In that sense, without a grounding in the state of our education, and the apparent options, ALL other inquiries (about anything), are shallow and lacking understanding. Without further comprehension we seek to blame a villain for all of our predicaments. But it is really us, and our own non-involvement.
Actually I have a ton of material. It is a very big work, maybe a year??? We'll see if I can sustain it. My plan is not to ship books to you, nor provide links. I hope to read them (they’re excerpts or chapters, not the whole book), and give you an overview. Later, if people begin to adhere to this thread, I may pass chapters and let you review them too. (So far I am giving links to the material too.)
There are a lot of issues, and each one has its proponents, and their reasoning, and its detractors, and their reasoning. It is going to have to be us that must sort it out, and determine what could be an improvement. I will be trying to come up with balanced views.
So far I have quickly put in a “pad” of initial posts. These were the easy ones developed in the past, but that will slow down. Please open this Edu 6. and you’ll see what it is all about. Also Edu 1. turn your thinking upside-down.
__________________
Edu 6. I’VE COME TO TAKE STOCK ON WHAT THIS PROJECT MIGHT ENTAIL
EDUCATION THEORY HAS ISSUES. Take a look at these two visions of what is needed in our society: Thanks for reading urge2evolve’s Substack! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work. OR HOW ABOUT THIS ONE?
1 Edu. A new theory of learning can revise thoughts on education
Creative Experience If the environment permits it, anyone can learn whatever he chooses to learn; and if the individual permits it, the environment will teach him everything it has to teach. Perhaps "Talent" or 'lack of talent" have little to do with it.
THIS ONE really must not be missed. It is a theory of learning based on decades of experience. It says anyone, regardless of background, can learn most anything, that “talent” and aptitude take a back seat. But it takes an environment that doesn’t squash them.
2 Edu. If I write about Education, what would I say?
a). It’s not only about what students learn, but strong desire to keep learning. To sustain intellectual curiosity, and wonder. It’s not just to transmit knowledge, but it is to become reflective people. Is a student one who knows a lot of stuff, or is a good thinker, can think, care, imagine, understand and adapt, and is an autonomous learner? Not onl…
3 Edu. I'll be reading some chapters from John Taylor Gatto
I am going to starts some readings on education. There are many issues and some authors suggest what to build on and others tell what must go. There is much to be for & against. We’ll see how far I get with it, but it all is fascinating. _____________ Here’s Gatto:
4 Edu. Here is more reading from Gatto
They’re designed to be instruments of the scientific management of mass population. Schools are intended to produce, through application of these formulas, formulaic human beings whose behavior can be predicted and controlled. In some experimental schools in Massachusetts children were given whole lives instead of age-graded ones in cell blocks; they lea…
5 Edu. Quotes from John Taylor Gatto
John Taylor Gatto > Quotes (He died Oct 25th 2018, at the age of 83. He was sick for a while.) John Taylor Gatto quotes (showing 1-25 of 83) “When you take the free will out of education, that turns it into schooling.” ― John Taylor Gatto “I've noticed a fascinating phenomenon in my thirty years of teaching: schools and schooling are increasingly irrelev…
Edu 7. Educators' comments so far say: Kids are half the time in school and half on Television
For their initial study in 1998, Gidney and Dobrow had a team of coders analyze 323 animated TV characters using measures such as ethnic and gender identification, physical appearance, hero/villain status, and linguistic markers. The coders tested a random sample of 12 shows, which spanned a variety of networks, air-times, and genres. Their findings sug…
Edu 8. Talk of school closure, and Community Schools
This is an update on an age-old controversy that we will be covering in all future articles. Should schools concentrate on academic excellence, and making the best learners better, or should schools dedicate much of their time and budget for inclusiveness projects and remedial learning?
Edu 9. My 1st Experiment to review a book chapter with screen shots
If you are not interested, that is none of my concern. (Anyway, it took me 7 years to get to it), and I don’t guarantee I will finish it this time. I DON’T KNOW HOW I WANT TO PRECEED? Thanks for bearing with this experiment. I am not going to be able to write a definitive review on 50 book chapters. This is also because I cannot copy/paste, due to these…
Edu 10. My 2nd Experiment to review a book chapter with screen shots
[These are the last of my screen shots from 3 years ago. I have also included the Gatto one’s that were already here in earlier posts. I had evidentially re-typed those graphics back then. FROM HERE FORWARD I WILL BE MORE ORGANIZED, and I will review these resources one-at-a-time. There is some very powerful material here.] It is not meant to agree…
Edu 11. This one book has changed my views on Education in America, and on Christianity.
[Some of the other books in this series seem to be from the point of view of "armchair educators", (the administrators), and armchair politicians who are at war with their contrasting theories. This book is full of (very moving), testimonies from dedicated caring teachers, and their very appreciative students.]
Edu 12. I really like Mike Rose in “Possible Lives”
We have two chapters from Rose’s book. - Intro repeated from Edu 11: For four years Mike Rose, director of the UCLA Writing Program, visited classrooms, collecting 100’s of anecdotes of dedication, from rural Montana to New York City. At a time when faith in public education was at its nadir, Rose finds redeeming attributes in America's greatest democr…
Edu 13. I am also reading E. D. Hirsch, "the Knowledge Deficit", 2006
And that reading is not just the mechanical learning of sounding out words, and then you can be unleashed on any subject. He says that a (very) broad base of knowledge is at the foundation of reading or communication into any other expertise. Building up this broad base, (of facts) is the function of education in the formative years. He quotes Thomas …
Edu 14. Scathing reports of increased school budgets and FLAT, immovable performance.
This may be a controversial book, but not because it lacks methodology. It is well researched and well written. It’s just because it publicizes results that are not desired. Out of maybe 91,000 schools, of course you meet every kind of situation imaginable. I wonder if you ever could generalize or come up with a “national standard” for education. N…
Edu 15. A most uplifting book is Herbert Kohl, The Discipline of Hope.
Kohl was sixty when he wrote this book, but the first chapters start when he was 24 and teaching sixth grade in Manhattan. He was born in 1937, and now he’s 86. I have three chapters of the book, including that first one. I highly recommend all three, which I’ll give download links to.
16 Edu. What is an authentic life?
[This was applied to “authentic teaching.”] It is a life-long individual project of sorts: to become the truest, finest, most harmonious and complete version of oneself. In contrast to an authentic life are lives characterized by alienation, reaction, artificiality, mindlessness, discordance, and cliché. The former view of life underscores your and my …